(2012) (Clint Eastwood, Amy Adams) (PG-13)
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.
- QUICK TAKE:
- Drama: A veteran baseball scout's failing vision causes his estranged daughter to help him watch a hot prospect.
- Gus Lobel (CLINT EASTWOOD) is a veteran baseball scout for the Atlanta Braves, but young upstart associate director of scouting Phillip Snyder (MATTHEW LILLARD) thinks it's time to put the old man out to pasture, and he's trying to convince GM Vince Freeman (ROBERT PATRICK) to replace Gus with computer stats. That doesn't sit well with Pete Klein (JOHN GOODMAN), Gus' longtime boss and friend, although he's noticed some issues with Gus of recent.
Accordingly, he contacts Gus' daughter, Mickey (AMY ADAMS), and alerts her to the fact that her dad might lose his job, which is all he lives for. Mickey, a lawyer in an Atlanta law firm with a strong shot of being named a partner, wants little to do with her father due to their past issues. But guilt eventually forces her to head to North Carolina to help Gus scout hot high school prospect Bo Gentry (JOE MASSINGILL).
Despite his situation, Gus isn't happy to see Mickey and doesn't want her help, but reluctantly allows her to stay. Her baseball knowledge comes in handy and it also impresses rival scout Johnny Flanagan (JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE), a former pitcher who Gus previously recommended for the team and who had a promising career until an injury ended that.
He takes a liking to Mickey, but she doesn't have time for him as she's always working on her latest case when not watching games with Gus and trying to let him know how his past behavior scarred her. As they try to sort that out, a budding romance develops between Mickey and Johnny, all while Pete tries to keep the Braves front office from retiring the veteran scout.
- OUR TAKE: 5.5 out of 10
- In the fall of 2011, a little movie by the name of "Moneyball" put a fresh spin on an old and frankly rather tired cinematic convention, the baseball movie. Beyond the terrific performances (both Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill were nominated for Oscars) and brilliant screenplay (Aaron Sorkin and Steven Zaillian were also nominated), one of the additional beauties of the film was that it took what would otherwise appear to be a dreadfully boring and hard to film subject matter -- statistics -- and make it seem fun, lively and entertaining.
In short, Hill played a numbers cruncher who -- based on a true story -- devised a new way to use all sorts of varied stats in determining the best players to combine to create a winning team. All of which was much to the chagrin of the old veterans -- especially the scouts -- who didn't appreciate the young upstart getting all fancy with them using numbers and such.
If I didn't know any better, I'd guess I somehow missed Gus Lobel sitting in the back of one such room, grumbling and growling about such people messing with the time honored tradition of scouting ball players. He's the lead character in "Trouble With the Curve," another baseball flick that could be considered the anti-"Moneyball" sports movie of 2012.
In it, Clint Eastwood somewhat takes up where he left off in "Gran Torino," once again playing a squinting, wrinkled and cantankerous sort who doesn't like a young stats guy (Matthew Lillard unfortunately bereft of Sorkin's dialogue or Hill's charisma playing the de facto antagonist) wanting to put him out to pasture. In fact, it doesn't appear he really likes most anyone (save for some similarly aged scouts who serve as both his competition and drinking buddies), and his blurred vision from macular degeneration has only further fouled his mood.
Thus, he's really peeved when his adult daughter (a ravishing Amy Adams) shows up to help him scout a new prospect (Joe Massingill) and thus not get fired from his job, all at the request of his old friend and boss (John Goodman). The twist, though, is that she doesn't like her father for reasons left mysterious to the viewer until the third act when they're finally revealed, and thus their pairing in a small North Carolina town is tenuous at best.
It's nothing we haven't seen before (in terms of estranged parent-adult child relationships, sports movies and such), but director Robert Lorenz -- working from a script by Randy Brown -- manages to infuse enough realism, charm and entertaining moments into the mix that it all goes down fairly easily, but also lightly (meaning it likely won't follow its 2011 predecessor and score multiple Oscar nominations).
The filmmakers do get a lot of winning mileage out of introducing Justin Timberlake as a former hot pitcher turned rival, but friendly scout. He also shows up to watch the new player, but his interest turns to checking out Adams' "I'm so busy I'll keep you at arm's length" character. While there's similarly nothing new to that particular setup, the two young performers take the material and run with it, likely to the light delight of most viewers.
It's the relationship between the father and daughter, though, that's at the core of the story and Eastwood and Adams make it work despite the clichés and conventions that envelope their characters (he the crusty old generation type who'd rather seem ornery and mad than let his true emotions out, she the overworked young professional trying to break through the old boys network and mindset at her law firm). Again, there's nothing new here, and the writing isn't anywhere near the caliber of what "Moneyball" knocked out of the park.
That said, I was never bored at any point and enjoyed more moments than I didn't. While "Trouble With the Curve" isn't a grand slam of baseball movies, it's a solid pop fly and double that gets the job done. It rates as a 5.5 out of 10.
Reviewed September 12, 2012 / Posted September 21, 2012
If You're Ready to Find Out Exactly What's in the Movies Your Kids
are Watching, Click the Add to Cart button below and
join the Screen It family for just $7.95/month or $47/year
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.
All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2021 Screen It, Inc.