Back when Dave Johnson (MORRIS CHESTNUT) and Clarice Clark (TARAJI Darnell. HENSON) were married in 1995, their future together looked bright, especially with the blessing of their pastor, Bishop Wilkes (ALBERT HALL). Now, however, Dave's once promising but injury-derailed baseball career is just a past memory, and he runs a small home repair business. On the other hand, Clarice has been quite successful in real estate, winning salesperson of the year over her friend and coworker Michelle (NIECY NASH).
Her success, however, leaves her with no time or desire for children, meaning Dave has to do the surrogate father thing coaching little league with his friends Tree (KEVIN HART) and Brock (EDDIE CIBRIAN), and ends up disgusted that ex-con Darnell (WOOD HARRIS) doesn't treat his own son, Deshawn (NATHANIEL CARTER), the way he should.
Dave and Clarice's already troubled marriage is further strained when he's late for her awards ceremony and they're hit by another vehicle on the way. As a result, her leg is badly damaged, leaving her depressed and bitter, and her opinionated mother, Mary "Mama" Clark (JENIFER LEWIS), moves in to care for her and blames Dave for being a bad husband.
Things look up when therapist Julie Sawyer (MAEVE QUINLAN) shows up to work with Clarice. A single mom whose son, Bryson (CANNON JAY), is a competitive swimmer, Julie helps Clarice heal physically and mentally. Yet, as Clarice emulates her mother's negative view of men, and Dave's desire to be a father draws him to Bryson and thus Julie, the couple must deal with additional strains and setbacks regarding their marriage.