This film, a remake of the 1949 production, "The Heiress," and based on the Henry James novel, has its work cut out for it right from the start. That's because the original film, starring Olivia De Havilland and Montgomery Clift, was nominated for many Academy Awards and won De Havilland an Oscar for her role as Catherine (and the film also won for best Music, Production Design, Costumes, and Art Direction). Fortunately few audience members know of that earlier version and thus this remake gets a chance to stand on its own. And it does just that with great performances from Leigh and Finney (a four-time Oscar nominee) that will delight "art house" crowds but will probably not gain much of a crossover audience into the mainstream. The highlight of the feature is Maggie Smith's take on the supporting character of Lavinia. Her constantly busy matchmaker activities provide the film with some much needed comic relief -- albeit brief -- that lightens up the somewhat depressing story. A five-time Oscar nominee and one-time winner, Smith is a delight to watch. Production values are first-rate (much like the original) with the costuming, props and cinematography expertly capturing the period feel.
While mainstream audience members who are used to complex or action-filled plots may find this film to be too much of a "costume drama," others will revel in its more mature approach to storytelling. Simply the story of a father/daughter struggle, the production allows Leigh and Finney to show off their acting skills. Although it's doubtful that Leigh will win -- or for that matter be nominated -- for her performance, it's still very good and she lends her usual suppressed fieriness to her role. Finney is absolutely superb in his role and may just get an Oscar nod in the Best Supporting category while Chaplin (the love interest in "The Truth About Cats & Dogs") also delivers a competent performance. While not a ground-breaking or exciting feature, "Washington Square" showcases great performances in a slow-paced but satisfactory plot. We give this film a 7 out of 10.