[Screen It]

(2005) (Mark Wahlberg, Tyrese Gibson) (R)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

Drama: Four adopted brothers band together to find and enact revenge on those responsible for their mother's murder.
When Evelyn Mercer (FIONNULA FLANAGAN) is murdered in a convenience store robbery, her adult adoptive sons reunite in their hometown of Detroit to attend her funeral and settle her estate. Bobby (MARK WAHLBERG) is a former hockey player who never made it to the pros and seems the most affected by her death. Ex-hustler and military man Angel (TYRESE GIBSON) is happy to be back home since that means he'll get to see his former girlfriend Sofi (SOFIA VERGARA). Youngest son Jack (GARRETT HEDLUND) is a gay musician, while Jeremiah (ANDRE BENJAMIN) is the only sibling who remained in Detroit where he's settled down with wife Camille (TARAJI P. HENSON), dabbled in business real estate and sworn off the brothers' earlier rambunctious and troublemaking ways.

Their childhood friend turned cop Lt. Green (TERRENCE HOWARD) suspiciously eyes their reunion, but he has a vested interest in solving their mother's murder since he spent many a day in her home with the others. After going through the normal grieving period, Bobby, Angel and Jack decide they want to find their mother's killer and deliver their own form of justice on them. Jeremiah isn't keen on the idea, and once they've started their detective work, Green and his partner Fowler (JOSH CHARLES) want the siblings to leave such matters to them, but the brothers can't.

They eventually come to the realization that the murder may have involved local crime boss Victor Sweet (CHIWETEL EJIOFOR) who was indirectly involved in some of Jeremiah's business attempts and whose influence spreads throughout the community and even to various authority figures. As the brothers continue their investigation and go after him, they run the risk of becoming just as bad as those they're after in the name of revenge.

OUR TAKE: 3.5 out of 10
Ghosts have long appeared in works of fiction, whether that's in the form of novels, plays, movies or TV. While they're usually of the scary variety, they sometimes show up for comedy, and at others, they serve as moral compasses for those who need some guidance in their lives before doing something rash or stupid. One need only look at the works of Shakespeare for such examples.

In "Four Brothers," a ghost is similarly used, but not to impart information to the audience as oft occurred in the Bard's writing, or to warn of pending tragedy. Instead, the ghost of Evelyn Mercer -- gunned down in a convenience store by some hoods after trying to set a potential future hoodlum on the straight and narrow -- appears to remind her four adopted and now adult sons about their table manners.

While that might make the movie sound like a comedy -- and at times, there's a surprising amount of humorous material -- this is really a tale of murderous revenge, with a subsequently high body count. And truth be told, the apparition really isn't a ghost per se, but rather a series of memories in each man's head about the mother they now miss.

Yet, where is she and/or the memories of her teachings when the four decide to go Chuck Bronson on whoever gunned down their dead old mum? That's one of the questions and one of many problems facing this odd hybrid of a movie that just doesn't work as conceived and/or executed and is never believable -- ghosts or not -- for a moment of its 100+ minute runtime.

Considering that it comes from the filmmaker responsible for "2 Fast 2 Furious," that really shouldn't be much of a surprise. Yet, director John Singleton also helmed "Boyz n the Hood," his 1991 debut that not only jump-started his career, but also proved he knew a thing or two about crafting a compelling and gritty, urban drama.

Unfortunately, and despite a smattering of effectively staged sequences (mostly of the action variety), the film just doesn't work. Perhaps stuck in the mindset from remaking "Shaft," the film feels and looks like one of those urban dramas from the 1970s, and a mediocre one at that, despite being set in 2004. From the shooting style to the soundtrack and even the performances, the film feels like it's from another era. Normally, that's not a bad thing, but it only adds to the overall misery here.

The biggest problem is the uneven and undulating tone. At times, the film is that very gritty revenge flick. At others, it's a familial drama that then segues into comedy. While I understand the need for comic relief in a tale of familial loss and revenge, there's simply too much of that. Coupled with some occasionally stiff acting, emotions that never feel authentic, and sketchily drawn villains, the result is a movie that doesn't know what it wants to be and thus comes off as a disappointment.

It certainly doesn't help that the script by David Elliot ("The Watcher") & Paul Lovett (making his debut) also makes the main gist of the tale -- the brothers investigating their mother's murder and following the trail straight to the killer -- far too easy for the brothers to accomplish and thus boring for the viewer to behold.

Despite the comedic underpinnings and brotherly element that's supposed to make us bond with the characters -- not to mention the supposed cathartic element of the revenge angle -- I didn't like any of the characters and thus didn't care if they succeeded or not. In other words, neither they nor the film engaged me beyond a few occasional visceral reactions to the violent action scenes.

Stemming from poorly written characters to lackluster performances, the acting isn't anything special and Mark Wahlberg ("I Heart Huckabees," "The Italian Job"), Tyrese Gibson ("Flight of the Phoenix," "2 Fast 2 Furious"), Andre Benjamin ("Be Cool," "Hollywood Homicide") and Garrett Hedlund ("Troy," "Friday Night Lights") simply can't do anything with their parts. Even Terrence Howard, so terrific in "Hustle & Flow," feels stiff in his role as the brothers' friend-turned-cop.

His co-star from that film, Taraji P. Henson is similarly limited playing the standard-issue, worried wife character, but both look like shining stars compared to Chiwetel Ejiofor as the head villain. A standout in "Dirty Pretty Things," he's a caricature of a '70s era villain here. His demands of telling a subordinate he must sexually share his girlfriend with him and making another eat off the floor like a dog are supposed to make him scary, yet he's anything but that.

Uneven, and never believable, engaging or even viscerally cathartic in a vendetta sort of fashion, "Four Brothers" is a hybrid of a film that simply doesn't have a ghost of a chance of working. It rates as a 3.5 out of 10.

Reviewed August 3, 2005 / Posted August 12, 2005

If You're Ready to Find Out Exactly What's in the Movies Your Kids
are Watching, Click the Add to Cart button below and
join the Screen It family for just $7.95/month or $47/year

[Add to Cart]

Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2018 Screen It, Inc.