[Screen It]
    

 

"MINORITY REPORT"
(2002) (Tom Cruise, Colin Farrell) (PG-13)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

QUICK TAKE:
Sci-fi: In a futuristic society where murderers are arrested before committing the crime, a cop goes on the run after a psychic vision shows he's about to murder someone.
PLOT:
It's the year 2054 and there hasn't been a murder in Washington, D.C. over the past six years due to the work of a police operation known as Pre-Crime. Run by Lamar Burgess (MAX VON SYDOW) who invented it with the reclusive Iris Hineman (LOIS SMITH), the system utilizes the premonitions of three psychics, known as Pre-Cogs - including Agatha (SAMANTHA MORTON) - who have visions of pending murders.

Examining and piecing together those fragmented views, cops such as John Anderton (TOM CRUISE) and his partner Gordon Fletcher (NEAL McDONOUGH) figure out who's going to kill whom as well as when and where the murder will take place. Racing against the clock, they then arrest the perpetrator before the event actually occurs, and then send them off to a prison containment facility overseen by Gideon (TIM BLAKE NELSON).

All of the system works and there's a plan to take it nationwide, but Danny Witwer (COLIN FARRELL) of the Justice Department has reservations about the legality and morality of the whole setup, especially when he learns that John is a drug addict whose wife, Lara (KATHRYN MORRIS), left him after their young son disappeared and was presumably killed years ago.

Things then become more complicated when John is seen in the next round of psychic visions as a pending murderer. Not recognizing the upcoming victim or why he might be inclined or forced to kill him, John goes on the run, eventually enlisting the aid of Lara, Agatha and an underground eye surgeon, Dr. Eddie (PETER STORMARE), all while trying to clear his name and figure out whether he's being set up or really will kill another person.

OUR TAKE: 7.5 out of 10
Due to the prevalence of murderers and their various means of killing people and then trying to get away with that, it's up to detectives and forensic scientists to figure out who, how and why they did it and then stop them from striking again. The problem with that, of course, is that it does no good for the previous victims.

Imagine then, if you could know ahead of time who would murder whom with the added benefit of throwing in the when and where variables. That was the futuristic scenario of author Philip K. Dick in his short story, "Minority Report," that's now been brought to the big screen by director Steven Spielberg.

Starring Tom Cruise in one of his better and more intriguing roles to date, the film tells the tale of a future society where police - thanks to the work of three psychics and their visions of the future - arrest murderers before they commit the crime and do so by examining and piecing together the details of those homicidal visions.

The "what if" hook then involves the twist of one of those cops then being seen in one of the visions and thus targeted for arrest despite not knowing or even recognizing the pending victim or having any idea why he might be inclined or forced to murder him.

Working from an adaptation of Dick's story by screenwriters Scott Frank ("Out of Sight," "Get Shorty") and Jon Cohen (making his debut), Spielberg mixes the philosophical implications of such a setup with enough action and sci-fi material to keep the nearly two and a half hour film moving along at a good and nearly always mesmerizing clip. Although it may go on too long like his last film - "A.I." - and miss what may have been its more appropriate ending point, at least it's not as ultimately disappointing as that other sci-fi flick.

One of the bigger reasons for that is that the film doesn't feel like a stereotypical Spielberg picture. While parts of "A.I." came off the same way (those with the late Stanley Kubrick's touch on them), others reeked of the sentimental and manipulative Spielberg tone that ruined that effort. Although this one momentarily teeters on that late in the film, its only other recognizable Spielberg element is some brief slapstick mayhem reminiscent of the filmmaker's work in, of all things, "1941."

Beyond that, the film is teeming with memorable action set pieces that are thrilling on their own and collectively add up to a film that - notwithstanding the brilliant "Saving Private Ryan" - is the director's best work in a long time.

From the work of Spielberg's longtime collaborator, cinematographer Janusz Kaminski ("Saving Private Ryan," "Schindler's List") and his de-saturated camera work to the many terrific special effects, a fun futurist view of the world (where moving animation/video exists on cereal boxes and newspapers, and advertising directly addresses the passerby by name) and composer John Williams' (the "Star Wars" and "Jurassic Park" films) effective but thankfully understated score, the film is nothing short of mesmerizing and compelling to behold.

That's not to say that the film is without its flaws, however, although many of them are far more script than director-based. While the specifics of how Pre-Crime works are seamlessly explained without seeming like overt exposition that needs to be gotten out of the way, a few important details have seemingly been omitted or overlooked.

For instance, we never learn of the range - physically or temporally - of the psychics' visions, a point that raises the question of how the DC-based program would work nationally. Then there's the overall philosophical and scientific debate and paradox of how the psychics could foresee murders that ended up never occurring due to their visions alerting the Pre-Crime units to intervene. Wouldn't they have had a vision of that occurring as well? It falls along the same lines of the usual time travel dilemma where a future event wouldn't occur if it were subsequently (or is it previously) prevented.

The bigger problem, however, is that Spielberg and the screenplay don't know when to call it quits. Had either had the guts to stop the film at its logical and ironic conclusion (which I won't give away), the film would have been so much better and ended with quite a mental kick. As it stands, the film drags on for quite a bit after what should have been its "Twilight Zone" like conclusion.

Much like "A.I." Spielberg then proceeds to provide something of a modified happy ending, while in this case also tying up the lose ends like any standard murder mystery where everything is explained at the end. It's not an awful development, but it proves to be the least original and/or interesting part of the story.

As the haunted protagonist, Tom Cruise ("Vanilla Sky," "Jerry Maguire") delivers a terrific performance that not only ranks as one of his best, but also ranks up there as far as playing a character in a Dick adaptation. Colin Farrell ("Hart's War," "Tigerland") is decent but not as good as the protagonist's adversary, which also holds true for Max Von Sydow ("Snow Falling on Cedars," "What Dreams May Come") as the Pre-Crime director.

The shaved Samantha Morton ("Sweet and Lowdown," "Jesus' Son"), however, is quite good, once freed of her confines, as one of the psychics. The likes of Kathryn Morris ("A.I.," "The Contender"), Neal McDonough (HBO's "Band of Brothers," "Star Trek: First Contact"), Lois Smith ("The Pledge," "Twister") and Peter Stormare ("Windtalkers," "Fargo") nicely complement the larger roles.

While not perfect, this sci-fi flick and its various scenes and sequences are likely to grow on viewers hours or days after seeing them, which is always a good sign. Featuring a fun premise, good performances, excellent technical work and one of Spielberg's best fantasy efforts, "Minority Report" rates as a strong 7.5 out of 10.




Reviewed June 17, 2002 / Posted June 21, 2002


If You're Ready to Find Out Exactly What's in the Movies Your Kids
are Watching, Click the Add to Cart button below and
join the Screen It family for just $7.95/month or $47/year

[Add to Cart]


Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2017 Screen It, Inc.