[Screen It]

(2002) (Bruce Willis, Colin Farrell) (R)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

Action/Drama: A young American officer finds himself representing a black officer accused of killing a white soldier in a German WWII POW camp.
Lieutenant Tommy W. Hart (COLIN FARRELL) is a young officer from a privileged background working in an Allied field headquarters in 1944 Belgium. Ordered to drive another officer to another location, the two are ambushed and Tommy is captured and imprisoned by the Germans. Briefly interrogated by officials interested in the location of Allied fuel dumps, Tommy is eventually sent to the POW camp in Augsburg, Germany.

There, he meets the German commandant, Col. Werner Visser (MARCEL IURES), who has no problem executing prisoners, as well as the ranking American officer, Colonel William McNamara (BRUCE WILLIS), who's in charge of the POWs. Sent to bunk with the enlisted men due to McNamara's belief that he ratted out secret information to the Germans, Tommy tries to fit in, especially with Staff Sgt. Vic W. Bedford (COLE HAUSER) who seems to have connections to get him whatever he needs.

When Lieutenants Lincoln A. Scott (TERRENCE HOWARD) and Lamar T. Archer (VICELLOUS SHANNON), two downed black pilots from Tuskegee are assigned to the same barracks, however, things go from bad to worse for Tommy. That's because Bedford and many others share racist attitudes and aren't happy to have two black men bunking with them.

After a related execution, a white soldier ends up dead and Scott is charged with the crime. McNamara manages to convince Visser that they must have a military trial, and that Tommy, who has two years under his belt at Yale Law School, should defend the accused. From that point on, Tommy tries to prevent Scott from being found guilty and executed, all while uncovering all sorts of interesting clues and facts about the truth.

OUR TAKE: 5.5 out of 10
When it comes to race relations in the U.S. few will deny that things have dramatically changed over the past half-century. Yet, most everyone will agree that there's still plenty of room for improvement. One of the ways that artists try to help out in such matters is by slipping such issues into a grander form of entertainment - be it dramatic or comedic - and thus educate viewers, with whatever message they may have, while diverting their attention - to one degree or another -- elsewhere.

Such is the case in director Gregory Hoblit's latest film, "Hart's War." What initially appears will be a standard WWII POW prison escape flick turns out to be a message movie as well, this time in the form of "Why can't we all just get along?"

That may come as a bit of a surprise to some viewers who've been mislead by the advertising campaign and movie poster, just like the fact that Willis - whose mug is the one that commands the movie poster - isn't the titular character and that it's not the tale of his war the movie's interested in telling.

Something of a combination of any WWII POW film (such as "The Great Escape" or "Stalag 17") and military trial pictures (such as "A Few Good Men" and "A Soldier's Tale"), the film has its moments and benefits from some good performances by some of it various performers. Yet, what amounts to didactic preachiness and an uneven mixture of its storylines prevents the film from being as good, moving or exciting as it might have been.

As written by screenwriters Billy Ray ("Volcano," "Color of Night") and Terry George ("The Boxer," "In the Name of the Father") -- who have adapted writer John Katzenbach's novel - the film includes the standard POW material regarding the Americans in the German stalag. There are the secret compartments and passageways, the somewhat respectful but still volatile repartee between the American officer and the German commandant, and the outsmarting of the guards.

From the military courtroom dramas of the past we have the green rookie who's in over his head trying to defend a suspect who has the odds stacked against him, as well as his interaction with a seasoned and gruff veteran who doesn't seem to like him.

For anyone who hasn't seen any such films, this one might come off as an exciting and engrossing experience. For those who have, however, the picture will likely feel like a mediocre retreading of various familiar elements from those previous movies, but without the crackling and smart dialogue or contagious energy.

Cases in point are two scenes that indicate the level of what's to follow. In one, the German Stalag commandant - who, natch, went to an American school before the war -- gleefully anticipates the pending military trial, stating that it will be something like he's seen in American movies. In the other, we see brief views of the POWs staging a theatrical show that includes caricatures of Hitler and the war.

Unfortunately, both scenes uphold their precursory nature and status as the film simply feels like so many other similar pictures that have preceded it, and does so not necessarily in a mocking fashion, but one that never manages to rise above its artifice.

It's not that Hoblit ("Frequency," "Primal Fear") does a hack job with the material, and for a while it's actually rather good as we follow the story of the titular character. Yet, once the standard POW material comes into play and then the race card is thrown into the mix, things get a bit too obvious and redundant. That wouldn't be so bad if they didn't get preachy as well, but that's exactly what occurs.

The problem is that we know there was racism and inequality in the '40s and that not all Germans were bad. The filmmakers, however, seem to think that either that's not the case or that we need to hear it one more time to make sure the message is received. It is, but to the point of being somewhat insulting and feeling like it's decades behind the times in delivering its message.

It doesn't help that things get more improbable and melodramatic as things eventually come to a head and expository revelations are made and/or uncovered. To some, the culmination of such material will be exciting, but to others it may become too preposterous and/or ludicrous to bear. The film certainly contains an ending that most won't see coming, but it also feels more contrived and unlikely (in terms of the number of involved people) than shocking.

All of that said, the performances are generally decent to good. Colin Farrell ("American Outlaws," "Tigerland") proves once again that he's a star just waiting for the right material to allow him to bud, flower and then take over Hollywood. Bruce Willis ("Bandits," "The Sixth Sense") plays something of the anti-hero here, and is a bit hard to buy at first. While I liked his character's nebulous qualities and the notion of his motives, the material somewhat hampers Willis' performance.

The most intriguing performance comes from Marcel Iures ("The Peacemaker," "Mission: Impossible") as the German colonel. Despite being saddled with some far too obvious contrivances - he listens to Negro jazz in his office - the actor brings some depth to his character and thankfully avoids most of the stereotypes - both dramatic and comical - usually associated with such characters.

Meanwhile, Cole Hauser ("Tigerland," "Pitch Black") plays a convincing bigot, and Terrence Howard ("Glitter," "The Best Man") and Vicellous Shannon ("The Hurricane," "Can't Hardly Wait") deliver solid performances as the two black flyboys who find themselves in a hornet's nest of unrest.

Decent at times but restrained and hampered by a script that's often both too familiar and too preachy, the film clearly isn't horrible. Yet, it's not great either, resulting in a mediocre effort that doesn't really have anything new to say or explore, but is relatively easy enough to watch and should benefit from the current patriotic atmosphere in the country. "Hart's War" rates as a 5.5 out of 10.

Reviewed February 11, 2002 / Posted February 15, 2002

If You're Ready to Find Out Exactly What's in the Movies Your Kids
are Watching, Click the Add to Cart button below and
join the Screen It family for just $7.95/month or $47/year

[Add to Cart]

Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2019 Screen It, Inc.