Ryden Malby (ALEXIS BLEDEL) is certain she has her life all figured out. Having just graduated from college, she already has a swanky apartment picked out just a block from the publishing house where her dream job awaits. Her best friend from college, Adam Davies (ZACH GILFORD), thinks she might be jumping the gun, especially since the job isn't hers yet. Even so, he admires her gumption, particularly since he can't decide between going to law school across the country or living at home with his father, Roy (J.K. SIMMONS), while pursuing a career in music.
Ryden's dream is shattered, however, when her lifelong academic rival, Jessica Bard (CATHERINE REITMAN), gets the job instead of her. As a result, Ryden has to move back home with her family, and to make matters worse, she's temporarily without a car due to hers being wrecked.
Her luggage store manager dad, Walter (MICHAEL KEATON), says he can fix it, but is preoccupied with new business ventures when not obsessing about the cat owned by their infomercial director neighbor, David Santiago (RODRIGO SANTORO). Her mom,
Carmella (JANE LYNCH), is worried that Ryden's younger brother, Hunter (BOBBY COLEMAN), is weird, but Walter's mom, Maureen (CAROL BURNETT), says all members of the Malby family are that way.
As Ryden deals with all of that, the now disillusioned college grad must reassess her career path, all while falling for David and without realizing Adam's true feelings for her.