Paul "Wrecking" Crewe (ADAM SANDLER) is a former, MVP caliber, professional quarterback who was banned from the league years ago for point shaving. When he goes on a drunken driving spree in his girlfriend's car and causes a huge pileup of police cars, he's sent off to prison. Arriving at the Allenville Federal Penitentiary, he quickly learns -- thanks to a brutal reception by head prison guard Capt. Knauer (WILLIAM FICHTNER) -- that his three-year sentence is not going to be easy.
Knauer, who's in charge of the prison's football team, wants to ensure that Paul will turn down an invitation by Warden Hazen (JAMES CROMWELL) to be involved with the team. Yet, when Paul realizes the warden is even more dangerous than the guards, he reluctantly agrees and advises Hazen that the best thing for his team is to scrimmage another. Hazen then orders Paul to put together a team of inmates for that very purpose. Since he's not very popular with the cons, Paul gets his new best friend, Caretaker (CHRIS ROCK), to do the recruiting.
Among those who eventually join the team is Switkowski (BOB SAPP), a huge but illiterate man; Cheeseburger Eddie (TERRY ALAN CREWS) who can get burgers for anyone; overweight Big Tony (JOEY "COCO" DIAZ); overeager but untalented Brucie (NICK TURTURRO JR.); mad Torres (LOBO SEBASTIAN); running back Earl Megget (NELLY); and Deacon Moss (MICHAEL IRVIN). When the likes of Joey Battle (BILL GOLDBERG) and 7-footer Turley (DALIP SINGH) learn that they'll be playing guards Lambert (BILL ROMANOWSKI), Dunham (STEVE AUSTIN), Garner (BRIAN BOSWORTH) and Engleheart (KEVIN NASH), they quickly sign up as well.
With the help of coach and former Heisman Trophy winner Nate Scarborough (BURT REYNOLDS), the team starts practicing, but must put up with efforts by Hazen, his guards and prison snitch Unger (DAVID PATRICK KELLY) who will do anything to make sure the team loses in the big game between the convicts and guards.