Mort Rainey (JOHNNY DEPP) is a novelist living in a cabin on the lake who's seen better days. Not only did he discover his wife, Amy (MARIA BELLO), in bed with another man, Ted (TIMOTHY HUTTON), six months earlier, but the thought of that and their pending divorce has left him with writer's block.
Spending most of his time sleeping on his tattered sofa, Mort's status goes from bad to worse when a stranger, John Shooter (JOHN TURTURRO), shows up at his doorstep one day, claiming the author stole and published the work he previously wrote.
Mort claims innocence, but Shooter is intent on the writer making things right and warns him that this matter is just between them. Given just three days to prove he wrote it before the stranger takes action, Mort seeks help from local Sheriff Dave Newsome (LEN CARIOU), but the lawman doesn't seem too concerned.
Mort then turns to New York detective Ken Karsch (CHARLES S. DUTTON) who previously helped him in a similar matter and agrees to take care of Shooter. Yet, as Mort tries to deal with that and come to terms with Amy wanting to finalize their divorce, little does he know how things will unexpectedly spiral out of control.