Amanda Pierce (MONICA POTTER) is a Renaissance painting restorer at the Met in Manhattan who thinks she has the worst judgment in men when it comes to romance. Her lesbian coworker, Lisa (CHINA CHOW), thinks it's silly that Amanda gets weak in the knees over paintings rather than men, but Amanda says that they're easier to deal with.
That proves to be true when she comes home to find her live-in boyfriend in bed with a model, so Amanda sets out to find a new place to live. She does so in a closet that's been converted into a bedroom and then rented out by a quartet of models, Jade (SHALOM HARLOW), Roxana (IVANA MILICEVIC), Candi (SARAH O'HARE) and Holly (TOMIKO FRASER), who live there for free and get a long list and line of men to pay for all of their other needs.
When the models realize that Amanda is attracted to Jim Winston (FREDDIE PRINZE, JR.), a fashion executive who lives in the building across the street, they give her a quick makeover and crash one of his parties. There, Amanda and Jim learn that they're kindred spirits and agree to go out on a date. Yet, when Amanda returns to her place and gazes down into Jim's, she thinks sees the silhouette of him murdering a woman.
Of course, no one else saw this and the police don't believe her report, but Amanda and her new roommates then set out to prove whether or not Jim actually committed the crime. While doing so and seeing him dealing with a shady businessman, Halloran (JAY BRAZEAU), Amanda finds herself torn between completely falling for Jim and worrying that he may indeed be a killer.