Dennis (TIMOTHY OLYPHANT) is a gay 28-year-old, West Hollywood photographer who's begun to grow tired of having casual sex and is looking for something more. As he does so and attempts to provide some guidance to Kevin (ANDREW KEEGAN), a 23-year-old who's just starting to come out of the closet, his various gay friends also find themselves confronting their sex, social and love lives.
There's Cole (DEAN CAIN), the handsome actor who seemingly has no problem leading a life filled with nothing but casual sex. Howie (MATT McGRATH), on the other hand, hasn't been able to get over his breakup with Marshall (JUSTIN THEROUX); Benji (ZACH BRAFF) finds that he's looking for love and sex in all of the wrong places; while Taylor (BILLY PORTER), the most flamboyant of the bunch, has just been dumped via a long distance phone call.
Patrick (BEN WEBER), who laments the fact that he's not as good looking as his friends, faces an entirely different dilemma. His sister, Anne (MARY McCORMACK), wants him to donate his sperm to her lesbian lover, Leslie (NIA LONG), so that they can have a child together.
As the men hang out at the "Jack of Broken Hearts" restaurant and club owned by their "mother hen," Jack (JOHN MAHONEY), and discuss all things homosexual, the men try to sort out their various relationships and ideologies about their romantic lives.