Upon hearing the title, "Buena Vista Social Club" the more Hollywood savvy may think the film
concerns an Orlando or L.A. based watering hole or dance hall where the likes of Mickey, Minnie, Donald, Pluto and yes, even Michael Eisner hang out and the mere mention of Jeffrey Katzenberg will draw leers and/or have you kicked out on your keister.
No, the film has nothing to do with Disney, although several of the people appearing in it were probably already at work when Steamboat Willie first graced the silver screen back in the late 1920's. And for those who think that The Rolling Stones and other similar "over the hill" groups are too old to still be touring and performing, by the time Mick Jagger realized he wasn't getting any "satisfaction" behind his baby crib slats, some of the performers in this film were already starting into midlife crisis territory.
Yes, long before current heartthrob Ricky Martin or even Latino star Selena were making waves, a group of talented musicians were creating wonderful music along the shores and in the capital of pre-Castro Cuba. All but since forgotten, many of them, including the likes of singers Ibrahim Ferrer and Omara Portuondo, guitarist Compay Segundo, pianist Ruben Gonzalez and several others were brought together in 1997 by acclaimed producer and musician Ry Cooder to record an album, "The Buena Vista Social Club."
As such, this film -- helmed by German director Wim Wenders who's best known stateside for his 1987 film, "Wings of Desire" (that inspired the Nic Cage/Meg Ryan pic, "City of Angels") -- is a returned favor to Cooder for composing the soundtracks for several of Wenders' films. It's also an example of minimalist documentary filmmaking.
Taking an approach that's something akin to what the multi-night documentary "The Beatles Anthology" did for that well-known group (as compared to the earlier, chronological, and narrator-driven "The Compleat Beatles"), this film allows the musicians and their music to tell their stories in an unencumbered manner. Considering the fun swing and salsa style music, that's not such a bad idea and we're treated to numerous pieces of performance and recording studio footage.
However, while such moments are entertaining to watch, this documentary as a whole leaves a bit to be desired. Before seeing it, my knowledge of Cuban music consisted mostly of having seen some recorded Desi Arnaz performances. After seeing it, that's still pretty much the case although I now at least know the names of a few legendary performers.
That's because unlike other documentaries, such as the "Behind The Music" series on cable TV channel, VH1, we're told very little about the musicians or their music. Although each performer is seen recollecting some moment from their past -- with several of the members receiving far greater focus than the others -- such informative moments are very brief. As such, we never really learn much about them or the history of Cuban music from past to present.
Since most of these performers were around in the pre-Castro days when Cuba was a glorious destination and vacation hot spot -- and now often looks like a third world country in the footage presented in this film -- the most obvious question of how Castro's regime affected and/or still affects the musicians and their music -- is never approached.
Beyond that, the film has the typical documentary look -- courtesy of cinematographer Jörg Widmer -- with different film stock being used and the camera work ranging from motion- sickness inducing shakiness to fluid Steadicam work that beautifully floats around the musicians during a recording session.
The film does have some fun moments including one where one of the performers briefly mentions Che Guevara playing golf with Fidel Castro -- and obviously allowing the latter to win -- as well as a window-shopping spree in New York where the musicians -- many of whom had never been to the United States -- try to identify pictures and/or cutouts of various famous Americans and see the city as a beautiful thing.
It's that trip to the Big Apple and the subsequent performance in Carnegie Hall -- the Valhalla for musicians -- where the film is the most satisfying. Performing to an enthusiastic, sold out audience, these hardworking, longstanding performers finally get their due recognition and the effect is quite pleasing.
As such, one can't help but smile along with seventy-something singer Ibrahim Ferrer as he accepts a standing ovation, finally receiving some well and long-deserved recognition outside his native country. The moment is heartwarming, and fans of these performers and Cuban music overall will most likely heartily enjoy the entire proceedings.
For the rest of us, this documentary is certainly easy enough to sit through, features some entertaining music, and may have audiences leaving with a better appreciation of it. One only wishes, however, that as a documentary -- of which many will argue the true cinematic definition -- that it taught us more about these performers and their music, particularly considering their longevity before and after Castro took over Cuba. Fun, but in our opinion not particularly life changing or properly educational, "Buena Vista Social Club" rates as a 6 out of 10 on our musical scale.